Creepy Urban Legends Trivia Trivia Quiz - Trivia Quiz

1 In the classic 'Vanishing Hitchhiker' legend, what do drivers often discover after dropping the passenger off?

A. The car refuses to start until sunrise.

B. The driver later learns from relatives that the passenger died years earlier at that spot.

C. She secretly steals the driver’s wallet.

2 Which urban legend warns that saying a name into a mirror multiple times will summon a spirit?

A. Bloody Mary

B. The Banshee

C. The Jersey Devil

3 The legend of 'Polybius' centers on what supposed effect of a mysterious arcade game?

A. Dispensing coins instead of tickets.

B. Printing secret maps to hidden treasure.

C. Causing players to suffer memory loss, nightmares, and illness, amid rumors of government tests.

4 What creature is said to haunt Point Pleasant, West Virginia, with glowing red eyes and wings?

A. The Mothman

B. The Fresno Nightcrawler

C. The Flatwoods Monster

5 In the cautionary tale 'The Hook,' what clue reveals the escaped killer’s presence?

A. A cryptic message carved into a tire.

B. A bloodied hook left hanging from the car door handle.

C. Missing car keys found in a tree.

6 Which legend features children with entirely black eyes who ask to be let into homes or cars?

A. Pale teens who scatter pennies on porches

B. Hooded figures that only appear in reflections

C. Black-Eyed Children

7 The urban legend about alligators living in New York City's sewers claims they arrived how?

A. They migrated through storm drains from Florida.

B. Former pet alligators were flushed or released into sewers and grew to monstrous size.

C. A circus train crashed beneath the city.

8 In the tale 'The Licked Hand' ('Humans Can Lick Too'), what does the protagonist realize?

A. The 'dog' turns out to be a friendly neighbor.

B. The house was actually vacant all along.

C. The comforting lick wasn’t from the dog, implying an intruder in the house.

9 Which legend tells of a woman who weeps while searching for her drowned children?

A. La Llorona, the 'Weeping Woman' seeking her drowned children

B. A mermaid who trades voices for wishes

C. A banshee who guards mountain passes

10 What do the 'Black Volga' or 'Black Sedan' legends typically describe?

A. A limousine that grants fortunes to hitchhikers

B. A sinister black car that abducts people and is never traced

C. A cursed taxi that circles only on leap years

11 The 'Choking Doberman' story concludes with what twist?

A. The dog was poisoned by a neighbor’s plants.

B. The dog swallowed a wedding ring that solves a mystery.

C. The dog was choking on human fingers from a burglar still in the house.

12 What does the Pop Rocks-and-soda urban legend claim can happen if you mix them?

A. It permanently stains teeth bright blue.

B. It turns soda into a harmless gel.

C. It could make a person’s stomach explode (myth).

13 Which tale involves a babysitter receiving unsettling calls that turn out to be coming from inside the house?

A. The Call of the Wendigo

B. The Phantom Switchboard

C. The Babysitter and the Man Upstairs

14 In Japanese folklore, which spirit asks 'Am I beautiful?' while wearing a mask?

A. Teke-Teke

B. Kuchisake-onna, the Slit-Mouthed Woman

C. Yuki-onna, the Snow Woman

15 The 'Bunny Man' legend from Virginia centers on sightings of what?

A. A giant rabbit that steals crops

B. A mysterious family of tunnel-dwellers

C. A figure in a rabbit costume seen near a bridge, sometimes wielding an axe